Skip to main content

My experience in saving for college as a new parent -- funding a 529


When I was a senior in high school my mom came into my room and had one of the briefest and realest conversations with me that I have ever had.  I was working on college applications and still in the process of figuring out which schools I would apply to.  I had created a list of 10 schools.  Most were schools that had admission standards that I could meet, in cool locations, and close to friends who I had grown-up with.  I think she knew at the time that I was looking at schools that fit that criteria instead of investigating other important items such as:

- Which schools specialized in the majors that I was interested in?
- Which schools had a proven track record of helping undergraduates find employment after graduation?
- Costs of tuition versus benefits

So, my mom comes into my room and says to me, “Son, you can go to a state school and we’ll be fine, or you can go to a private school and our family will struggle”.  I nodded, and understood the situation.  I changed that list from 10 to 4, all SUNY schools.

I can say with no hesitation that I had a great college experience.  I went to SUNY Albany.  I met great people, had a quality education, made the most of the opportunities presented to me, and walked out with zero debt.

Now as a new parent, I have been thinking about how to set up our family so that we can provide the academic, emotional, and financial support so that our son can go to the best possible school that he can get in to.  Full disclosure, this isn’t a knock against my mom or anything like that.  I wasn’t exactly the best student and she did for me what a lot of people (including myself) dream of, which is to have her child graduate from a decent school with no debt (Thanks Mom!!).

As most of you know, states have sponsored programs called 529s.  The program name 529 comes from the Internal Revenue Source Code 26 U.S.C. 529.  529s are programs that allow a family to invest in a higher education fund that provides tax advantages.  You can use the earnings to pay for higher education expenses such as tuition, room and board, books, equipment, and other college related expenses.    

I can only speak from my experience, and as a New York resident, you have two options when investing in a 529.  You can enroll in a direct plan or an advisor led plan.  So, what are the main differences between the two?

A direct plan is:

- Cheaper
     o   It has a lower expense ratio since you are not paying an advisor.
- You will determine the asset allocation on your own
     The direct plan has recommended asset allocation options, such as by age where the funds are selected for you.
           § For example: If you select the age fixed settings
                  o   Age 0 to 5 – will be 100% Stocks
                  o   Ages 5 – 10 – will be 75% Stocks and 25% Bonds
                  o   Ages 10 14 – will be 50% Stocks and 50% Bonds
                  o   Ages 14 to 18 – will be 25% Stocks and 75% Bonds
                  o   These are just rough estimations, these aren’t exact numbers but this is how the age                             settings work.
- The available fund options are all index funds


An advisor led plan:

- Costs more
     o   You are paying to have an advisor
- You will have guidance on developing an investment plan
     o   Your advisor will discuss time frames and asset allocations with you
          §  Although, and this is my opinion, you can figure this portion out on your own if you put in a 
             bit of research.  A great resource to read to develop an investment philosophy is the                              Intelligent Investor by Graham (Which I’ll write about in my next post).
- You may be privy to different funds.
     o   I don’t know this for a fact since I don’t use an advisor, but other blogs have stated that an        
         advisor led account may provide actively managed fund options.
          §  As a note, it is my understanding that over an extended period, actively managed funds do 
             not beat out the returns of an index fund.  However, if you believe that this is the route you                  want to go, I completely respect that.  But, do note that an actively managed fund will no                    doubt incur greater expenses, which will eat into your returns.

So, what I’d like to share with you today is my experience in developing a plan for my son’s 529 plan. 

First, I went with a direct plan, because I wanted to keep my expenses as low as possible.  To open an account all you need is the social security number of your child, and the rest is as simple as creating any other generic account.

Second, you must determine your asset allocation.  Since I have been reading the Intelligent Investor as I am simultaneously planning our son’s college savings fun, I’m following Graham’s recommendation of at least 75/25 in any direction.  
What that means is at the riskiest you should be 75% stocks and 25% bonds.  And, at the most conservative you should be 75% bonds and 25% stocks.  So, since our son is young, I’m going to be risky, and then re-assess the situation as he gets older.  
In addition, read about the funds that you are investing in, and then sleep on it before you fund the account.  If you do not like the allocations, you can always change it later, but it is best to be sure in your decision and stick with your plan.

Third, you must plan backwards and determine how much money you will need to invest.  My father in-law gave me this wonderful tool that helps in determining how much money you will need to set aside to meet your financial goal.

Also, most ‘experts’ are projecting college expenses to be through the roof 18 years from now.  CNBC/BuzzFeed wrote a short article on projected expenses in the future for college.

The decision is up to you as to whether you put stock into projections like this.  Nonetheless, you should develop a number in mind and work backwards from there using the tool from the Vanguard website. 

Lastly, stick to your financial plan and fund the account. 

I hope this post was helpful, and I look forward to hearing any of your comments, thoughts, questions, or feedback!! 

Thank you for reading and please hit the subscribe button at the top!!


P.S. Mom, if you are reading this.  Thank you.  For everything.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

9 Core Values to Help Disciplined People to Steadily Build Wealth

This post is for people who are self-disciplined and looking to invest money outside of their employer sponsored retirement plans.  It is also for those who are aspiring to find ways to generate passive income.

As an educator in New York City, we are provided an employer sponsored 403-b called the Tax Deferred Annuity (or TDA for short).  For more information on it, I wrote about some of my observations about educators and retirement in an earlier article called A little bit goes a long way. 

For those who are not familiar with TDA, it offers a variety of investment options but the most promising is the guaranteed returned fix rate for UFT members at 7% annually, and 8.25% for all other members. The maximum contribution that an individual can make is $18,000 for the year, which is similar to a traditional IRA for everyone else.

If you find yourself in a unique situation where you still have money to invest then I would like to share some of my own ideas that I have put into practice.…

7 Key Traits Required For Stock Selection.

In Chapter 14 of Benjamin Graham's The Intelligent Investor, he focuses on the 7 items for defensive stock selection.

In the preface, this chapter is highlighted by Warren Buffett as one of the keynote chapters, and therefore the reader should pay special attention to the advice that Graham offers.

For those who are unfamiliar with Benjamin Graham he was a former fund manager, professor, and is considered the father of value investing.  Value investing is a strategy where stocks are purchased at less than their intrinsic value.  Intrinsic value in layman's terms is the amount the company is worth (Assets - Liabilities = Worth).

By the way, the equation above is not the actual method for finding intrinsic value, it is just a gross oversimplification of what it means.  I would also like to note that intrinsic value is different than the stock price.  The stock price is what the market is valuing the company at, but it may not reflect its intrinsic value.

For example: 

Let's …

Review on the Purple Cow - Transforming your business by being remarkable by Seth Godin

The Purple Cow by Seth Godin is a book on marketing, and focuses on the modern day environment.  Godin believes that the traditional methods of advertising are broken and ineffective.  He defines traditional advertising as companies that follow the P's of marketing: Pricing, Promotion, Positioning, Packaging, Pass-Along, Permission, and Publicity.  Godin believes that the key to successful advertising is by creating a remarkable product.  The metaphor that he uses for a remarkable product is a purple cow.

The idea is that a purple cow is unheard of, and therefore it is a remarkable thing.  Godin believes that modern day marketing tactics should focus on just one P, the purple cow.

Godin then provides cases in which remarkable products launched companies to the forefront of their industries.  An example is Google.  It is a website that has a slot where you can type in text and two buttons.  One of the buttons is completely arbitrary.  Yet, it has become the lead search engine and…